D&D 5E - I think that there's an issue with squeezing.

Posted by Valentine Belue on Sunday, July 7, 2024
The PHB states that a creature can squeeze through a space (at half speed) big enough for a creature one size smaller than it. The trouble is that a Small creature takes up the same space as a Medium creature, which is presumably to make working with a grid easier when you have a mixed party of Humans, Elves, Halflings, Gnomes, etc. but the end result is that the only PCs which can fit through a gap smaller than 5` wide are the Halflings and Gnomes.

I'd consider this a deliberate feature which allowed the sneaky Halflings to get to places a larger race can't, but a real world human can fairly easily fit down a 2` or even 1` corridor if they have to. I usually support abstract ideas over realism if they enhance the gameplay, but this just seems to push it a bit too far for me.

Anyone out there got thought, a fix, or will you just be ignoring it and ruling if a PC can fit somewhere case-by-case?

(For those with the PHB, it's on p.192 for reference.)

ncG1vNJzZmivp6x7prrWqKmlnF6kv6h706GpnpmUqHyqedOhoKejXam1osCMrZ%2BeqpWoeqK6jKKqrK2VYsSqwMdmqqqtlZrHqrrGZ2pucGVnfXA%3D